Sacramento’s Beloved Zelda’s Pizza: A Cherished Comeback Story

Zelda’s Original Gourmet Pizza: A Second Slice at Life in Sacramento

In the heart of Midtown Sacramento, there’s a local legend that has stood the test of time, serving as a cherished gathering spot for generations. Zelda’s Original Gourmet Pizza, a beloved pizzeria with a history spanning over four decades, recently made headlines with an unexpected twist. After closing its doors in August, marking the end of an impressive 45-year run, Zelda’s has now reopened, much to the delight of loyal patrons who feared they’d never taste its famous Chicago-style pies again.

The surprise announcement came via Zelda’s Instagram account, reigniting hope and excitement among its devoted customer base. The reopening, however, came with some changes. The restaurant is currently only offering takeout and accepting cash payments, a nod to old-school simplicity in a digital age. Despite these adjustments, the overwhelming enthusiasm from the community has proven that Zelda’s legacy is as strong as ever.

“When they reopened, it was like, ‘Oh my goodness,’” shared Barry Hutcherson, a long-time customer who, like many others, was ecstatic at the news. Leslie Niver, another loyal fan, echoed Hutcherson’s sentiments, saying, “I was ecstatic.”

Nostalgia Meets New Beginnings

The revival of Zelda’s comes under the new ownership of Beau Cornell, a Sacramento native with a deep appreciation for the pizzeria’s legacy. Cornell’s goal is to maintain the essence of Zelda’s while ensuring its success in the years to come. “It is the old Zelda’s but better,” Cornell said confidently.

While some may fear that change could compromise tradition, Cornell’s approach is refreshingly respectful. “We are changing things very barely, aesthetically. Pizza is the same, the guys in the kitchen have been there for 15 years, and they are staying,” he explained.

In fact, business has been booming since the reopening. “We have been selling over 100 pies a day. Sometimes we sell out in two hours,” Cornell noted, a testament to both the quality of the food and the strong bond between Zelda’s and its customers.

A Symbol of Resilience and Community

Zelda’s closure last August was more than just the end of an era; it was a stark reminder of the challenges faced by small businesses in recent years. From pandemic-induced restrictions to economic uncertainties, the path has been anything but smooth. The impact of these closures isn’t just financial—it’s deeply personal.

For the Sacramento community, the loss of Zelda’s felt like losing a piece of their own history. “It is really important to patronize these businesses, especially such a unique business as Zelda’s,” said Jody Pribyl, a long-time fan who lauded the pizzeria as the best place for Chicago-style pizza in Northern California.

Leslie Niver expressed a sentiment that resonated with many. “It’s sad. It makes you feel old. It’s like, ‘I used to go there. Well, they are not there anymore.’ For them to close suddenly, everyone was pretty much shocked,” she said. The return of Zelda’s has not only reignited fond memories but also strengthened the communal spirit.

Familiar Tastes, Familiar Faces

Zelda’s charm has always been more than just its food. It’s the memories made within its walls, the shared laughter over a slice, and the faces of the people who have worked tirelessly behind the scenes. “I am never surprised by how popular Zelda is, was, and will be,” Pribyl added. The pizzeria has become more than a restaurant; it’s a symbol of connection and continuity.

This continuity is palpable even in its current operations. While in-person dining remains on hold, there’s an undeniable sense of homecoming when customers pick up their orders. “It is so much nicer. You can keep going to the places you are used to; it feels like home,” said Niver.

A Revival That’s Just the Beginning

The overwhelming demand and support have bolstered Cornell’s optimism for the future. Plans are already underway to reintroduce in-person dining in the coming weeks, a move that many patrons eagerly anticipate. The idea of once again gathering at 1415 21st Street, exchanging stories, and savoring the iconic flavors that defined so many lives, is one that fills the community with excitement.

The story of Zelda’s revival is more than just the reopening of a pizzeria—it’s a testament to resilience, loyalty, and the powerful role that local businesses play in the fabric of a community. As Sacramento’s residents look to the future, Zelda’s stands as a reminder that even in times of uncertainty, cherished traditions can find new life.

So, if you find yourself in Midtown Sacramento from Thursday to Sunday between 5 p.m. and 9 p.m., consider stopping by Zelda’s. Whether you’re a lifelong fan or a newcomer eager to taste what all the excitement is about, you’ll find more than just a meal—you’ll experience a slice of Sacramento’s enduring spirit.